In a statement this week, following an extraordinary meeting of the Withdrawal Agreement Joint Committee, European Commission Vice President, Maroš Šefčovič said the adoption of the Bill would ‘constitute an extremely serious violation of the Withdrawal Agreement and of international law’. He warned the EU ‘will not be shy in using’ legal mechanisms enshrined in the Withdrawal Agreement, if the UK reneges on its commitments. Legal remedies include fines and trade sanctions.
The row erupted this week, creating unprecedented tensions between the UK and EU as the eighth round of talks concluded. Only one further round of negotiations remains before 15 October, the date set as the cut-off point by the Prime Minister, after which the UK will proceed to a ‘no-deal’ position of trading under World Trade Organisation rules.
The Bill gives ministers powers to ‘disapply’ rules relating to the movement of goods between Northern Ireland and Great Britain and make regulations on how the provisions of the Northern Ireland Protocol on State aid are to be given effect in the event of a no-deal Brexit ‘notwithstanding’ any incompatibility with international law or domestic law.
Downing Street has said the Bill is a necessary clarification of the Withdrawal Agreement, which had been ‘agreed at pace in the most challenging possible political circumstances’. Attorney-General Suella Braverman issued a statement defending the Bill under the principle of Parliamentary sovereignty.
Northern Ireland Secretary Brandon Lewis had earlier admitted in the House of Commons that the Bill would break international law in a ‘specific and limited way’, prompting mounting criticism from, among others, two former Conservative Prime Ministers, United States Democrats and senior Conservatives.
Former PMs Theresa May and John Major have both expressed concern that the Bill breaches international law and therefore undermines trust and respect in the UK. Nancy Pelosi, US Democrat and Speaker of the House of Representatives, tweeted: ‘The Good Friday Agreement is the bedrock of peace in Northern Ireland. If the UK violates its international agreements & Brexit undermines the Good Friday accord, there will be absolutely no chance of a US-UK trade agreement passing the Congress.’
Sir Bob Neill, who chairs the Justice Select Committee, has tabled an amendment to the Bill that would create a parliamentary veto on any changes to the Withdrawal Agreement.
Bar Council chair Amanda Pinto QC said: ‘We share widespread concern about the government’s stated intention to break international law in publishing new legislation on customs rules in Northern Ireland.
‘It should not need to be said that this country is built on, and subject to, the rule of law. Undermining this vital principle will fatally puncture people’s faith in our justice system, both at home and internationally. Someone committing a crime in a in a "specific and limited way” nonetheless commits a crime, and an admitted breach of international law in a "specific and limited way” is nonetheless a breach.’
Law Society president Simon Davis said: ‘The rule of law is not negotiable.
‘Our commitment to the rule of law is key to attracting international business to the UK and to maintaining faith in our justice system.’
Ursula von der Leyen, President of the European Commission, tweeted: ‘This would break international law and undermines trust. Pacta sunt servanda = the foundation of prosperous future relations.’
The Scottish Government said the Bill requires its consent under constitutional rules, as it engages the Sewel Convention. It opposes the Bill.
View the government’s legal position at: bit.ly/35sZBzw.
Read the ‘Statement by the European Commission following the extraordinary meeting of the Withdrawal Agreement Joint Committee’ at: bit.ly/33gqsfC.
