header-logo header-logo

Retain or return?

15 May 2008 / Sara Partington , Charlotte Yallop
Issue: 7321 / Categories: Features , Company , Regulatory , Commercial
printer mail-detail

Sara Partington and Charlotte Yallop revisit the often-ignored law of conversion

The recent High Court case of Schwarzschild v Harrods Ltd [2008] EWHC 521 (QB), [2008] All ER (D) 299 (Mar) has revisited the law of conversion (and its roots alongside detinue) and clarified that, for a cause of action in statutory conversion to arise (and limitation to start to run), both a demand that goods be returned and an unequivocal refusal to return them are required.

The judgment of Mr Justice Eady also sets out a useful review of the law in detinue and in particular the tort of conversion in accordance with the Torts (Interference with Goods) Act 1977 (T(IG)A 1977). It will be of interest to practitioners and to any entity whose business involves bailment or the treatment, dealing in, or retention of goods.

The Facts

In 1955, the defendant contracted with the claimant's mother (M) to rent a safety deposit box for her to store jewellery. Rental payments had ceased

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Quillon Law—Neil Dooley

Quillon Law—Neil Dooley

Disputes firm expands fraud and investigations practice with partner hire

Charles Russell Speechlys—Vadim Romanoff

Charles Russell Speechlys—Vadim Romanoff

Firm strengthens corporate tax and incentives team with partner hire

Burges Salmon—Gary Delderfield & Alec Bennett

Burges Salmon—Gary Delderfield & Alec Bennett

Partner and senior associate join pensions team

NEWS
In this week's NLJ, Sophie Houghton of LexisPSL distils the key lesson from recent costs cases: if you want to exceed guideline hourly rates (GHR), you must prove why
With chronic underfunding and rising demand leaving thousands without legal help, technology could transform access to justice—if handled wisely, writes Professor Sue Prince of the University of Exeter in this week's NLJ
NLJ columnist Stephen Gold dives into the quirks of civil practice, from the Court of Appeal’s fierce defence of form N510 to fresh reminders about compliance and interest claims, in this week's Civil Way
Mazur v Charles Russell Speechlys [2025] EWHC 2341 (KB) has restated a fundamental truth, writes John Gould, chair of Russell-Cooke, in this week's NLJ: only authorised persons can conduct litigation. The decision sparked alarm, but Gould stresses it merely confirms the Legal Services Act 2007
The government’s decision to make the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) the Single Professional Services Supervisor marks a watershed in the UK’s fight against money laundering, says Rebecca Hughes of Corker Binning in this week's NLJ. The FCA will now oversee 60,000 firms across legal and accountancy sectors—a massive expansion of remit that raises questions over resources and readiness 
back-to-top-scroll