header-logo header-logo

Oceans apart?

04 February 2010 / Deborah David
Issue: 7403 / Categories: Features , Mediation
printer mail-detail

Deborah David compares & contrasts US & UK mediation styles

There is no limitation on general damages in the US (except in clinical negligence cases), and cases are typically tried by jury. For US defendants, the risks of a jury trial in terms of quantum exceed those in the UK. Still, uncertainty remains whenever the facts are submitted for determination to a third party. For every litigant delighted by the results, there is an opposing litigant who had confidently predicted a different outcome.

In CN cases, the US healthcare system discourages early mediation to a greater degree than does the UK system. Physicians are independent contractors, and the liability policies insuring them contain a clause preventing settlement without their consent. Physicians on whose behalf a payment is made are reported to a data bank where the information is available to the public.  Consequently, doctors frequently withhold consent, making mediation pointless. However, in those cases that do mediate, the settlement rates are in the range of 80%.

In the UK, with its national healthcare, logic suggests

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Hugh James—Phil Edwards

Hugh James—Phil Edwards

Serious injury teambolstered by high-profile partner hire

Freeths—Melanie Stancliffe

Freeths—Melanie Stancliffe

Firm strengthens employment team with partner hire

DAC Beachcroft—Tim Barr

DAC Beachcroft—Tim Barr

Lawyers’ liability practice strengthened with partner appointment in London

NEWS
Ceri Morgan, knowledge counsel at Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer LLP, analyses the Supreme Court’s landmark decision in Johnson v FirstRand Bank Ltd, which reshapes the law of fiduciary relationships and common law bribery
The boundaries of media access in family law are scrutinised by Nicholas Dobson in NLJ this week
Reflecting on personal experience, Professor Graham Zellick KC, Senior Master of the Bench and former Reader of the Middle Temple, questions the unchecked power of parliamentary privilege
Geoff Dover, managing director at Heirloom Fair Legal, sets out a blueprint for ethical litigation funding in the wake of high-profile law firm collapses
James Grice, head of innovation and AI at Lawfront, explores how artificial intelligence is transforming the legal sector
back-to-top-scroll